Monday, February 22, 2010

Revisionism and Emma's Gender Change - Again

This is an update to an article first posted in July, 2008. Emma, who once was a female angel, had gender re-assignment surgery in June of 2008. Amazingly, she is now female once again. With God "all things are possible."

"I'm not talking about Emma, the female healing angel."
-Todd Bentley 2/21/10 at Morningstar
In order to understand Todd Bentley and to make sense what is going on at Morningstar, you must first understand Bentley’s angelology. For most of us, angels are not central to the gospel; they are "waiting in the wings" as it were. Why does his angelology cause so much controversy? Well, here's a quote from Bentley while at Lakeland:

"I told the Lord why can't I just move in healing and forget talking about all that other stuff?" "Because Todd, you've got to get the people to BELIEVE IN THE ANGEL"..."And I said God, why do I want people to BELIEVE IN THE ANGEL? Isn't it about getting people to BELIEVE IN JESUS?"...And He Said, "People already believe in Jesus, but the church doesn't believe in the supernatural."

The issue here. as I see it, is not that angels might be upstaging Jesus (which may be a valid issue) but rather Todd's reported conversation with God, in which God instructs Todd to "get the people to believe in the angel." That is not a valid commission by God, it is "another gospel."

When Bentley talks about "the angel" he is often talking about the named angel "Healing Revival" that only Bentley and a few others have purportedly "seen." This angel, whom he also calls "The Angel of the Lord" whispers words on knowledge into his left ear. I'm just wondering out loud if we should take his word for it. Well, this angel has now shown up at Morningstar, but of course, only Todd can see it. He said "you didn't see it of couse, it was a spiritual thing" implying that the rest of us...uh, you can see where this is going.

He has mentioned "The Angel of the Lord" hundreds, if not thousand of times, in his meetings. Often he alternatively states that Jesus is whispering in his left ear, as he gains his healing "words of knowledge." The Old Testament phrase, "The angel of the Lord" refers to Jesus in pre-incarnate form. If he is calling the post-ascension Jesus an angel, a created being, he is simply being blasphemous.

The confusion, in Bentley’s mind, has been longstanding. At a Toronto meeting circa 2004 Bentley stated:

"This might not even be an angel, it might actually be Jesus, The angel of the Lord. So maybe it wasn’t an angel that came to me maybe it was actually Jesus."

We are trusting this man to discern spirits?

Aside from the amazing fact that Bentley has mentioned more "named angels" than the whole of the scripture, he teaches that we have many personal angels at our beck and call.

"When I need a financial breakthrough I don't just pray and ask God for my financial breakthrough. I go into intercession and become a partner with the angels by petitioning the Father for the angels that are assigned to getting me money: "Father, give me the angels in heaven right now that are assigned to get me money and wealth. And let those angels be released on my behalf. Let them go into the four corners of the earth and gather me money."

And apparently, using angels to gather money is quite successful.

“Now let me talk about an angelic experience with Emma. Twice Bob Jones asked me about this angel that was in Kansas City in 1980: "Todd, have you ever seen the angel by the name of Emma?" He asked me as if he expected that this angel was appearing to me. Surprised, I said, "Bob, who is Emma?" He told me that Emma was the angel that helped birth and start the whole prophetic movement in Kansas City in the 1980s. She was a mothering-type angel that helped nurture the prophetic as it broke out. Within a few weeks of Bob asking me about Emma, I was in a service in Beulah, North Dakota. In the middle of the service I was in conversation with Ivan and another person when in walks Emma. As I stared at the angel with open eyes, the Lord said, "Here's Emma." I'm not kidding. She floated a couple of inches off the floor. It was almost like Kathryn Khulman in those old videos when she wore a white dress and looked like she was gliding across the platform. Emma appeared beautiful and young-about 22 years old-but she was old at the same time. She seemed to carry the wisdom, virtue and grace of Proverbs 31 on her life.

She glided into the room, emitting brilliant light and colors. Emma carried these bags and began pulling gold out of them. Then, as she walked up and down the aisles of the church, she began putting gold dust on people. "God, what is happening?" I asked. The Lord answered: "She is releasing the gold, which is both the revelation and the financial breakthrough that I am bringing into this church. I want you to prophecy that Emma showed up in this service-the same angel that appeared in Kansas city-as a sign that I am endorsing and releasing a prophetic spirit in the church." See, when angels come, they always come for a reason; we need to actually ask God what the purpose is. Within three weeks of that visitation, the church had given me the biggest offering I had ever received to that point in my ministry. Thousands of dollars! Thousands! Even though the entire community consisted of only three thousand people, weeks after I left the church the pastor testified that the church offerings had either doubled or tripled.”

While many people would make a big thing about a female angel, I'm even more concerned that Bentley's story seems to change with time.

In early 2008 more and more people were raising the issue of the lack of biblical precedent for an female angel. Bentley had a few other fires to put out at that time, and so it appears that Emma morphed into Ernie- in response to the questions.

"A while ago, Bob Jones told me about an angel that helped birth the entire prophetic movement in Kansas City in the 1980s. The Lord had sent this angel to help nurture the prophetic ministry (and gift), at a time when it was being re-established in the modern-day church in North America."A few weeks after our conversation, I attended a church service in Beulah, North Dakota. In the middle of the meeting an angel glided in. As I stared wide-eyed at the angel, I heard the Lord tell me that this was the same angel that was involved with the prophetic movement in Kansas City. The angel floated a couple of inches off the floor emitting a brilliant light and colors. He appeared young--about 22 years old--but old at the same time. It was as though he carried the wisdom, virtue, and grace of Proverbs 31.

From Bentley's The Reality of the Supernatural World, p. 230f:, June 2008.

Proverbs 31, of course, describes the virtues of an excellent wife. Darn, that sort of messes up the story, don't it?

Angels do far more than gather money for us. According to Bentley:

"We do not battle against flesh and blood, we do not battle with demonic power, the angelic hosts do."

Of course, this apparent paraphrase of Ephesians 6:12 contradicts the actual scripture.

"For we wrestle not against flesh and blood, but against principalities, against
powers, against the rulers of the darkness of this world, against spiritual
wickedness in high places. "

So it appears that Bentley not only makes up stories about what God told him ("The Lord answered: She...") but he also makes up scripture.

The choice is yours. Will you follow a man whose proclamations contradict the very Word of God, or will you remain faithful to the scriptures? This should not be taken lightly.

The real problem with telling stories is that you have to remember what you said previously so that you don't get caught in a lie.

And it never stops. Here, less than 2 years since Emma became a "He" once again Todd Bentley declares that Emma is a female angel. (Morningstar, 2/20/2010, timestamp 02:21:58).

Bentley also claimed that night to have seen "a pillar of white light" from the ceiling to the floor. Yeah, I saw that too. And yes, they have smoke machines and blue lights on stage just in case God does not show up. Just like Nadab and Abihu.


  1. Rick Hiebert2/23/10, 10:52 PM

    Great catch! Great post too!

    Can you mention where exactly in last Sunday's service he mentioned Emma? Roughly is fine....I'd just like to hear it too...


  2. Rick,

    It was a Staurday evening service, the night before the re-re-ordination.

    (Morningstar, 2/20/2010, timestamp 02:21:58).


  3. Rick Hiebert2/25/10, 12:15 AM

    Thanks for your help!

  4. Thank you for the great work you do here--your librarian anointing is obvious! I have not plumbed the depths of your "reading room" yet, (I can't wait till I have more time!)and like the Greycoats, you are doing the truth-loving part of the Body of Christ a great service by preserving the history of Charismania in your archives before the revisionists delete it entirely.

    It is a war, and it is over the truth, and the pathetic checkered past of this discredited movement is the biggest battlefield. These guys are like every despot who expunges the history books as soon as their grasp on power is secure. But not on your watch. Keep up the good work.

    I've used you as a source for my "Shrewshape E-mails", and I'll update the Bentley angelogy to reflect these new developments, to your credit. Soldier on, brother!

    Thanks again!
    Karen Butler

  5. Tatted Todd and his Pet Angel Emma, back for the Comeback Tour.

    Second verse, same as the first...

  6. dust...female angels...portals....What is this? "Jesus Fights Star Wars"...LOLOLOL.


In the "Choose an identity" section - if you click Name/URL you can enter your name or at least a screen name. The URL is optional. Comment by NAME is encouraged, as all should own up to thier comments.